Why Organic Standards for Mushrooms and Pet Food Matter to New York Farmers

New York leads the nation in organic mushroom production and is a powerhouse in organic livestock farming. That’s why NOFA-NY was deeply concerned by the USDA’s proposal to rescind long-awaited standards for organic mushrooms and pet foods.

These proposed rules would have brought much-needed clarity and consistency to organic certification, helping farmers navigate standards more easily and increasing opportunities for organic products in the marketplace. Specifically, they would have opened up the market for organically produced mushroom spawn and substrates, and clarified that while animal by-products can be used in organic pet food, they are prohibited in livestock feed, supporting growth in both industries while protecting organic integrity.

Contrary to claims that fewer rules benefit organic farmers, unclear standards create confusion, erode trust in the organic label, and ultimately hurt producers.

The proposed rescission is part of a broader USDA effort to reduce regulatory “burdens,” but in the case of organic, these voluntary standards were developed with widespread support from the organic community, including the National Organic Standards Board, as a way to strengthen organic integrity and expand market opportunities.

At NOFA-NY, we believe strong, clear, and enforceable standards are essential for a thriving organic sector. Our community continues to push for rules that uphold organic integrity and create more opportunities for organic farms across New York and beyond.